When it comes to 3D printing, selecting the right material can feel overwhelming, especially for those new to the field. One of our clients approached us recently with a straightforward but crucial question. They needed to 3D print a prototype for a mechanical part but were unsure which material would best suit their project. Should they opt for PLA, ABS, or PETG? Like many others who reach out to us, they were unfamiliar with the materials' properties and needed guidance.
To answer this question, we decided to conduct a practical test. We 3D printed the same part using PLA, ABS, and PETG, giving us an opportunity to see and feel the differences. In this post, we share our expertise and results to help you determine which material might work best for your own projects. At the beginning, we challenge you to guess which material is which in the image provided - a fun way to test your knowledge of PETG vs PLA vs ABS. The reveal will come at the end.
Key Material Insights and Use Cases
PLA
PLA, also known as Polylactic Acid, is one of the most widely used materials in 3D printing. It is easy to use, making it a popular choice for beginners.
PLA generally melts at low temperatures between 374°F and 446°F, which minimizes the risk of warping during printing.
The material does not require a heated chamber to print effectively.
PLA is available in a wide range of colors, including metallic and transparent options. This makes it ideal for decorative items, aesthetic prototypes, and concept models.
While PLA is strong in terms of tensile strength, it is brittle and shatters under impact. Its low resistance to heat and chemicals limits its applications to non-functional parts.
If you need visually appealing, affordable prototypes or models for form and fit testing, PLA is a reliable option.
ABS
ABS, or Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene, is a durable material that excels in creating functional prototypes and mechanical parts.
ABS can withstand temperatures up to 221°F, making it appropriate for high-heat applications.
The material is highly durable and resistant to impact, bending under stress instead of breaking.
Printing with ABS requires a higher temperature range of 446°F to 518°F, along with a heated bed to minimize warping. An enclosure is recommended for consistent temperature control.
ABS emits fumes during printing, so good ventilation is critical.
ABS is best suited for mechanical parts, automotive components, and items that require strength and longevity. It is also easy to post-process, allowing for techniques such as acetone smoothing for professional finishes.
PETG
PETG, short for Polyethylene Terephthalate Glycol, is a versatile material that combines some of the best traits of PLA and ABS.
PETG offers strong impact resistance and flexibility, making it suitable for functional prototypes.
The material has good chemical resistance and can handle outdoor applications due to its UV stability.
PETG requires printing temperatures between 446°C and 482°C, and it is less prone to warping compared to ABS.
The material is durable and produces clean, glossy finishes with proper settings.
PETG is ideal for applications that need a balance between durability, flexibility, and ease of printing, such as functional models, outdoor components, and containers.
Comparison Table for PLA vs ABS vs PETG
Below is a detailed comparison of the technical characteristics for these three materials for FDM 3D printing technology.
Property | PLA | ABS | PETG |
Tensile Strength (MPa) | 45-70 | 40-55 | 50-75 |
Flexural Strength (MPa) | 50-110 | 60-75 | 60-80 |
Elongation at Break (%) | 2-10 | 20-30 | 20-25 |
Heat Resistance (°F) | 122-149 | Up to 212 | 122-176 |
Printing Temperature (°F) | 374-446 | 446-518 | 446-482 |
Available Colors | Extensive, including translucent | Limited | Moderate |
Why Material Selection Matters
Choosing the right material is not always about cost but about finding the perfect match for the project's requirements. While PLA is affordable and visually versatile, it lacks the mechanical strength of ABS and PETG. ABS provides durability and flexibility but requires careful handling during printing. PETG is a middle ground, offering strength and versatility with fewer printing challenges.
One often overlooked factor is color variety. PLA leads the pack with the widest range of vibrant color options, including unique metallic and translucent finishes. PETG offers a good range of colors but is slightly more limited. ABS typically comes in fewer color options, though it is often used for functional applications where appearance is secondary.
If your project requires visually striking prototypes, PLA is a clear winner. However, if you prioritize durability or functionality, color options may play a lesser role in your decision. For materials like PLA, ABS, and PETg, explore 3D printing tips and tricks for improving FDM print quality.
Final Thoughts and the Photo Reveal
Take another look at the photo provided earlier. Can you guess which material is which? Here is the reveal: from left to right, the prototypes are printed in ABS, PLA, and PETG. While the difference between PLA, ABS, and PETg may not be immediately visible, the technical characteristics we discussed make a significant impact in practice.
The next time you are deciding between PLA, ABS, and PETG, consider your project's specific needs. Whether you prioritize visual appeal, mechanical strength, or a balance of the two, there is a material that will work for you.
If you need guidance, please reach out to us. We will be glad to help you choose not only between PETG vs PLA vs ABS but also guide you through a broader range of 3D printing materials for various technologies, ensuring the best results for your project. With our expertise in 3D printing on demand, we can help you choose the best material and achieve outstanding results.
Commentaires